legal247

Deletion logs and metadata: can an employee demand disclosure in a dismissal case?

In brief

An employee may demand access to deletion logs and metadata from the employer's systems in a dismissal case where the evidence is relevant and access is proportionate under the Norwegian Dispute Act. In LG-2026-153234 Gulating Court of Appeal held that no special conditions apply to such evidence and that no indication of deletion or manipulation is required.

On 28 October 2026 Gulating Court of Appeal dismissed an appeal by two employer companies against a ruling on access to evidence in a dismissal case (LG-2026-153234). The companies were ordered to give the employee access to, among other things, a deletion or activity log for an HR storage area, metadata for board minutes and selection documents, and competence assessments of four other employees. The ruling clarifies whether special conditions apply when deletion logs and metadata are requested as evidence, and how objections based on trade secrets, legal privilege, confidentiality and data protection are to be assessed.

What was the case about?

The employee was dismissed in October 2025 and brought proceedings in February 2026, claiming that the dismissal was invalid and seeking compensation for economic and non-economic loss. The issues in dispute are whether the dismissal was objectively justified, whether there had been unlawful lay-off and pay reduction, and whether employer responsibility lay with one of the companies or with both jointly. On 7 September 2026 the District Court ordered the companies to give access to a long list of documents. The companies appealed the orders concerning the deletion log, metadata, competence assessments, handwritten notes from a meeting and internal communications about the suspension of pay.

The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal on all points and awarded the employee costs for both instances. The ruling concerns access to evidence only. Whether the dismissal was objectively justified has not been decided, and it is not known whether the ruling has been appealed.

Which conditions apply to access to evidence under the Dispute Act?

Under Dispute Act Section 21-5 a party has a duty to give access to evidence, and under Dispute Act Section 26-5 the court may order a party to produce documents within its control. Under Dispute Act Section 26-6 the request must identify the evidence clearly enough for it to be identified. The Court of Appeal emphasised that Norwegian law has no general discovery regime, but that the specification requirement may be relaxed where the documents are likely to have evidential value.

The evidence must be relevant. Under Dispute Act Section 21-7 the court may exclude evidence that is irrelevant or not capable of strengthening the basis for the decision to any significant degree, and the Court of Appeal noted that such exclusion should be exercised with caution during case preparation. Access must also be proportionate under Dispute Act Section 21-8 and the third paragraph of Dispute Act Section 26-5, weighing cost and burden against the importance of the dispute and the value of the evidence. Because these are discretionary procedural decisions, the Court of Appeal reviewed them only for whether they were indefensible or clearly unreasonable.

Can the employee demand deletion logs and metadata?

The Court of Appeal held that no special conditions apply to deletion logs and metadata. In its own words, translated from Norwegian, the court stated as follows.

The Court of Appeal cannot see that special conditions apply to access to system logs for electronically stored documentation.

Nor was it a condition that the employee alleged that documents had been deleted or manipulated. The log for the storage area holding organisation charts was relevant to the question of joint employer responsibility and to the management structure, and could therefore not be excluded as irrelevant. The metadata had independent evidential value because it may show when and by whom the board minutes, selection notes and other documents were created and modified. That in turn may show whether the assessments relied on to justify the dismissal were in fact made before the decision was taken.

For employers, the consequence is that documentation of a redundancy process is assessed not only by its content but also by its technical traces. A selection assessment dated before the dismissal, but shown by metadata to have been created later, will significantly weaken the employer’s evidential position.

When do objections based on confidentiality and data protection succeed?

None of the companies’ objections succeeded, and the reasoning shows how high the threshold is. The Court of Appeal had full jurisdiction to review prohibitions and exemptions from evidence, so the assessments below are applications of law and not merely matters of discretion.

Objection Legal basis Court of Appeal’s assessment
Trade secrets Dispute Act Section 22-10 The companies had not specified how the metadata could contain trade secrets
Legal privilege Dispute Act Section 22-5 The information from the meeting was in principle protected, but confidentiality was waived because the employee attended
Exemption to protect third parties Dispute Act Section 22-9 No indication that disclosure would cause substantial loss of reputation or welfare
Data protection GDPR and the Personal Data Act No bar to access, and the request for redaction failed
Confidentiality of pay data Working Environment Act Section 2A-1 and Dispute Act Section 22-3 No bar to the order concerning internal communications about the suspension of pay

On legal privilege, the Court of Appeal accepted that the information from the meeting was covered by the prohibition on evidence, with reference to HR-2025-1945-A. Because the employee personally attended the meeting at which the companies’ lawyer was present, the information was nevertheless no longer confided as against the employee. The Court of Appeal found that the District Court’s reasoning on this point was wrong, but that the result was correct. The companies were ordered to investigate whether the handwritten notes exist and to obtain them from the employee who wrote them.

The competence assessments of the four other employees concerned competence, personal suitability and social circumstances. The court acknowledged that the documents contain personal data, but found that the data protection rules did not prevent access in a case where the assessments are central to whether the selection was objectively justified.

What does the ruling mean for the employer’s deletion and logging routines?

The ruling means that system logs and metadata must be treated as potential evidence from the time a dispute can be foreseen. Deletion of documents or logs after an employee has announced proceedings may be given evidential weight against the employer, even where the deletion followed an ordinary routine. At the same time, GDPR Art. 5(1)(e) requires that personal data are not kept longer than necessary. Under GDPR Art. 17(3)(e) the duty to erase does not apply where the data are necessary for the establishment, exercise or defence of legal claims. The employer may therefore retain material relevant to a pending or announced dispute, but should document that decision. The rules on erasure are discussed further in the article on the right to erasure under the GDPR.

Access to evidence under the Dispute Act is a different route from the right of access under GDPR Art. 15, which is discussed in the article on subject access requests under the GDPR. An employee in dispute will often use both. The employer’s access to employees’ email and file areas is governed by separate rules, see the article on employer access to employee email.

What should the employer do in a redundancy process?

The employer should document selection in a redundancy process in a way that can withstand scrutiny of both content and technical traces by the opposing party and the court. Further articles on data protection in employment are available on the data protection topic page.

  1. Prepare selection criteria, competence assessments and board documents contemporaneously and before the decision to dismiss is taken.
  2. Avoid modifying or creating documents after the event without stating clearly in the document that it is a later amendment.
  3. Write competence assessments objectively and verifiably, on the understanding that they may be disclosed unredacted.
  4. Keep legal advice separate from meetings attended by the employee if confidentiality is to be preserved.
  5. Suspend automatic deletion of relevant file areas, mailboxes and logs as soon as a dispute can be foreseen, and document which data have been preserved.

Questions and answers

Must the employee allege that documents have been deleted or altered to obtain deletion logs and metadata?

No. In LG-2026-153234 Gulating Court of Appeal held that no special conditions apply to access to system logs, and that it is not a condition that the party alleges document manipulation. The decisive questions are whether the evidence is relevant and capable of strengthening the basis for the decision, and whether access is proportionate.

Can the employer refuse to disclose competence assessments of other employees on data protection grounds?

Normally not. The Court of Appeal found that neither the exemption in Section 22-9 of the Dispute Act nor the data protection rules prevented disclosure of the competence assessments of four employees, and it rejected the request to restrict access. Employers must expect their selection documentation to be read by the opposing party and the court.

Is the ruling relevant to cases other than dismissals?

The rules on access to evidence in the Dispute Act apply to all civil cases. The reasoning on system logs and metadata is therefore also relevant to contract disputes and other cases where it is disputed when and by whom a document was created or modified.

Next legal review: 31 December 2026