Insights
All analysis, sorted by date.
A free service paid for with personal data: can it be advertised as free?
On 19 November 2026 Advocate General Medina proposed in Case C-643/25 that a digital service is not a free service where consumers must provide personal data for commercial use. If the Court agrees, such marketing falls under point 20 of the Norwegian blacklist of unfair commercial practices, with no need to show that consumers were actually misled.
AI in recruitment: what does the GDPR require before the EDPB's 2027 enforcement action?
On 11 November 2026 the EDPB announced that automated decision-making and AI in recruitment will be the topic of the coordinated enforcement action starting in 2027. Employers that let a tool filter out applicants without a human assessing them take a decision under GDPR Art. 22, which requires an exception, human intervention and an explanation of the logic to the applicant.
The good faith standard in Norwegian contract interpretation: when is a party bound?
Under the Norwegian good faith standard, one party's divergent understanding may prevail if the other party knew of it. In HR-2026-2465-A of 17 November 2026 the Supreme Court held that it is not enough that the other party ought to have understood. It must have understood, and between businesses the threshold is high, particularly where the party relying on the standard drafted the terms.
Fundamental rights impact assessment: who must carry one out under the AI Act?
Under Article 27 of the AI Act, a fundamental rights impact assessment (FRIA) must be carried out before the first use of a high-risk system by bodies governed by public law, private entities providing public services, and deployers using AI for creditworthiness assessment or for risk assessment and pricing in life and health insurance. The obligation applies in the EU from 2 December 2027.
Cloud suspension clauses: when may the provider shut down an AI service?
Cloud suspension clauses in the standard terms of OpenAI, Anthropic, AWS, Google and Microsoft allow the provider to suspend the service immediately for policy breaches, security risks, non-payment and legal prohibitions, and to terminate the agreement. The customer rarely has a claim for damages. Notice, proportionate suspension, a wind-down period and data export must therefore be negotiated.
OpenAI intermediary approval: what does it mean for customers of AI platforms?
From 20 November 2026, OpenAI's Usage Policies require prior approval for intermediaries that give third parties direct access to OpenAI models, such as model routers and AI gateways. Applications that merely integrate the models into their own features are not covered. An intermediary without approval risks suspension, and the risk passes down the contract chain to its customers.
Reselling AI services: when does a business become a provider under the AI Act?
When reselling AI, a business is the provider under Article 3(3) of the AI Act where it offers a system it has developed or had developed under its own name. Under Article 25(1), distributors, importers and deployers also become the provider of a high-risk system where they put their name on it, substantially modify it or change its purpose so that it becomes high-risk.
Compulsory transfer in a shareholder agreement: when must an employee shareholder sell?
A compulsory transfer obligation in a shareholder agreement takes precedence over the non-mandatory pre-emption rules in the Norwegian Private Limited Liability Companies Act, even where the articles are silent. On 23 October 2026 Gulating Court of Appeal held that an employee shareholder's obligation arose on actual departure, not on formal termination, and that the price was book equity.
Deletion logs and metadata: can an employee demand disclosure in a dismissal case?
An employee may demand access to deletion logs and metadata from the employer's systems in a dismissal case where the evidence is relevant and access is proportionate under the Norwegian Dispute Act. In LG-2026-153234 Gulating Court of Appeal held that no special conditions apply to such evidence and that no indication of deletion or manipulation is required.
Prompt injection: which security requirements should an AI agent contract contain?
Prompt injection is an attack in which hidden instructions in text make a language model act against the business. The risk cannot be eliminated, so it must be contained through least privilege, human approval and logging. The contract should bind the vendor to concrete security measures, testing, notification of vulnerabilities and incidents, and liability proportionate to the risk.
Supplier data breach: who notifies, and when does the 72-hour deadline run?
After a supplier data breach, it is the controller that notifies the supervisory authority under GDPR Article 33. The supplier, as processor, must inform the customer without undue delay, and the 72-hour deadline normally runs from that point. The Amadeus case from autumn 2026 shows that the customer must still assess the risk and inform the data subjects itself.
Text and data mining in Norway: a new exception, and what are AI vendor indemnities worth?
The Norwegian Copyright Act currently has no text and data mining exception. Prop. 41 LS (2025–2026) proposes a new section 50 e permitting text and data mining of lawfully accessible works unless the rightholder has reserved its rights in an appropriate manner. Foreign case law is divided, and AI vendor indemnities carry broad exclusions and Irish governing law.
AI agent governance: what do the GDPR and the Norwegian DPA require?
AI agent governance is part of the controller's duty to implement appropriate technical and organisational measures under GDPR Articles 24, 25 and 32. On 28 October 2026 the Norwegian Data Protection Authority advised organisations to map their agents, restrict what the agents can access and do, give each agent its own identity and appoint a person responsible who can stop it.
App tracking and session replay: when is consent required?
App tracking requires consent under Section 3-15 of the Norwegian Electronic Communications Act where the app reads or sends information from the user's device for personalisation, recommendations or analytics. The exemption for what is strictly necessary is narrow. In October 2026 CNIL fined Fnac Darty EUR 7 million for such tracking and held that session replay always requires consent.
Press publishers' right and AI chatbots: what does the Advocate General say in C-250/25?
The press publishers' right under Article 15 of the DSM Directive may be infringed when an AI chatbot retrieves a press article in real time and reuses its expression in an answer, according to Advocate General Szpunar in C-250/25 Like Company. Decisive are unlawful access and whether the answer replaces the original. Training is, in his view, as a rule permitted under the TDM exception.
Meta's new terms: what does the injunction granted to Norwegian publishers mean?
The Oslo District Court has by interim injunction prohibited Meta from introducing Meta's new terms for business accounts against ten Norwegian publishers until their lawfulness is finally decided. The order was made without hearing Meta, which may demand a subsequent oral hearing under Section 32-8 of the Dispute Act. The injunction protects only the applicants.
The complaints against Scale AI: which rules govern the monitoring of platform workers?
On 27 October 2026, noyb filed five complaints against Scale AI with the supervisory authorities in Austria, France, Italy and the Netherlands. They concern tracking tools, biometric checks of annotators on the Outlier platform and unanswered access requests. As Scale AI has no main establishment in the EEA, each authority may handle its complaint itself, as may the Norwegian authority.
Chinese AI models: how does DeepSeek as an app differ from locally run model weights?
The risk of Chinese AI models depends on how they are used. The DeepSeek app and DeepSeek's API store personal data in China, which has no adequacy decision, so their use requires a transfer mechanism under Article 46 GDPR. Where the open model weights are run on in-house infrastructure or by a provider within the EEA, no transfer to China takes place, although supply chain risk remains.
Standard terms by reference: what does the Rototec judgment mean for liability caps?
Under Norwegian law, a reference to standard terms in a tender does not automatically make their limitations of liability part of the contract. In HR-2026-780-A (Rototec), the Supreme Court held unanimously that the reach of such a reference depends on its wording, presentation and placement, and that any ambiguity falls on the party that drafted the tender.
Digital Omnibus: what the Council mandate means for AI training, cookies and breaches
The Council's Digital Omnibus mandate was agreed in Coreper on 21 October 2026 and is not adopted law. The Council keeps the definition of personal data, allows AI development on the basis of legitimate interest, supports a 96-hour breach notification deadline and keeps the cookie rules in the ePrivacy Directive. Current law continues to apply in full in Norway.
Age verification under the GDPR: what Norway's 16-year limit means for platforms
Age verification must comply with the GDPR, in particular data minimisation (Art. 5(1)(c)), data protection by design (Art. 25) and the DPIA requirement (Art. 35). On 19 October 2026 the Norwegian government announced an age limit for platforms harmful to children, but no bill has yet been tabled. The EDPB favours methods that only reveal whether the user is above the threshold.
B2B email prospecting with inferred addresses: what do the GDPR and Norwegian law require?
In Norway, B2B email prospecting sent to an inferred address such as firstname.lastname@company requires prior consent under section 15 of the Marketing Control Act, as the address belongs to a natural person. Legitimate interest under Article 6(1)(f) GDPR may justify inferring and storing the address, but not sending marketing to it without consent. Generic addresses such as info@ are exempt.
Blocking AI agents: can an online shop shut them out? Amazon v Perplexity
Blocking AI agents through terms of use and technical barriers is open to an online shop. In Amazon v Perplexity, however, the US Ninth Circuit held on 4 August 2026 that it is the user who obtains access when the agent acts. Under Norwegian law the agent's purchase normally binds the consumer, while the risk of card misuse follows Financial Contracts Act §§ 4-2 and 4-30.
Data annotator monitoring: what should buyers require of AI vendors?
Data annotator monitoring is primarily the vendor's responsibility under the GDPR, also where annotators are contractors. The buyer may still incur liability through its own data, joint controllership and the Norwegian Transparency Act. Contracts should require a list of monitoring tools, a ban on advertising trackers, limited biometrics, human decisions on deactivation and audit rights.
Data protection due diligence in M&A: how do GDPR breaches affect the price?
Data protection due diligence establishes whether the target's data may lawfully be used and what fine and damages exposure comes with it. GDPR breaches reduce the price through lower data value, remediation costs and fine exposure under GDPR Art. 83, calculated on group turnover. Known issues are priced through specific indemnities, price adjustment or escrow.
EN 18286 and ISO/IEC 42001: which gives a presumption of conformity under the AI Act?
EN 18286:2026 is the first harmonised standard under the AI Act. Its reference was published in the Official Journal on 14 October 2026, and providers of high-risk AI systems that apply it are presumed to comply with the quality management system requirements in Article 17 to the extent the standard covers them. ISO/IEC 42001 certification gives no such presumption.
General-purpose AI models: what must the provider do, and what should the customer demand?
Under Article 53 of the AI Act, providers of general-purpose AI models must keep technical documentation, inform downstream providers, adopt a copyright policy and publish a summary of their training content. From 2 August 2026 the Commission may impose fines of up to 3 per cent of worldwide turnover. Norwegian customers should secure warranties, indemnities and access to documentation.
Holiday pay and multiple contracts with one employer: what does C-706/23 mean in Norway?
In C-706/23 of 8 October 2026 the Court of Justice held that holiday pay and meal allowances for an employee with multiple contracts with the same employer cannot be based on the full-time contract alone. Norwegian holiday pay is already calculated on all remuneration paid under Holiday Act § 10, so the ruling matters mainly for contractual benefits tied only to the main position.
AI in central government 2027–2029: what does the new common directive require?
From 2027, all Norwegian government agencies must work for greater efficiency and quality with particular emphasis on the responsible use of AI in central government. The requirement follows from circular D-3/2026 and the letters of allocation for 2027–2029. Each agency sets its level of ambition with the employee representatives and reports on measures and results in its annual report.
AI meeting minutes: what does the GDPR require for recordings and transcripts?
AI meeting minutes involve recording, transcription and draft minutes, and each step requires a legal basis under GDPR Art. 6. Datatilsynet recommends deleting the audio once the transcript exists, and the transcript once the minutes are final. Private businesses will normally rely on legitimate interests, must inform all participants before recording and should as a rule carry out a DPIA.
AI vendor terms for high-risk use: what do Anthropic, OpenAI, Google and Microsoft demand?
From 12 November 2026, Anthropic's Usage Policy requires a qualified person with authority to change the output to review AI recommendations on employment, credit, insurance and healthcare, and the affected person to be told that AI was used. OpenAI, Google and Microsoft have similar AI vendor terms. A breach may lead to suspended access, even though the AI Act does not yet apply in Norway.
Joint controllership: can a business rely on consent obtained by its partner?
Not without its own verification. In joint controllership under GDPR Art. 26, each controller must itself have a valid legal basis and be able to demonstrate it. On 2 October 2026 the Norwegian Data Protection Authority fined Xandr NOK 92 million because the company relied on Grindr's invalid consents and on a contractual ban on sensitive data. The decision was not appealed and is final.
Overtime exemption in Norwegian tech: when is a position particularly independent?
The overtime exemption for a particularly independent position under Working Environment Act § 10-12(2) requires that the employee genuinely decides the volume and timing of the work. Flexible hours are not sufficient, and client deadlines count. Developers, consultants and project managers governed by sprints, deliveries and on-call rotas will therefore rarely be exempt.
Can email, Slack and source code be sold as training data on winding-up or bankruptcy?
Email, Slack and source code may only be sold as training data where each category of data has a lawful basis. Personal data requires a legal basis and a compatible purpose under the GDPR, employees' mailboxes must as a rule be erased, and customer data processed as a processor cannot be sold. Code and customers' confidential information are bound by copyright, licences and confidentiality.
Automated decisions: what does Uber's EUR 825 million fine mean for Norwegian companies?
The Dutch data protection authority has fined Uber EUR 824.99 million because driver accounts were deactivated automatically without a human assessing the case, and because drivers were given too little information. Automated decisions with significant effects on individuals are prohibited as a starting point under GDPR Art. 22. Uber has appealed the fine.
AI agents and contracting: is the business bound by what the agent agrees?
Contracts concluded by AI agents bind, as a rule, the business that put the agent to work. Norwegian law has no specific rules on this, but the agent's order is probably treated as the business's own declaration. Exceptions may apply where the counterparty understood or ought to have understood that something was wrong. System limits and agreed ground rules manage the risk best.
AI content labelling: what does Article 50 of the AI Act require?
AI content labelling is required in the EU from 2 August 2026 under Article 50 of the AI Act. The provider of the tool must mark the content in a machine-readable format. The business using the tool must visibly disclose deepfakes and AI-generated text on matters of public interest. The regulation does not yet apply in Norway, but Norwegian businesses publishing in the EU may be caught.
AI smart glasses: what is allowed today, and what does the announced ban mean?
AI smart glasses are not banned in Norway today. If the wearer films other people beyond purely private use, the GDPR applies, and facial recognition in practice requires explicit consent. Use at work is a control measure under the Working Environment Act. On 5 October 2026 the government announced a temporary ban covering public places among others, but no bill has been put forward yet.
Merger filing in Norway: what do inaccurate details cost, and who bears the risk?
A merger filing to the Norwegian Competition Authority must be correct and complete. If the notifying party intentionally or negligently gives incorrect or incomplete information, the undertaking can be fined up to 1% of its turnover. SLB was fined NOK 30 million in October 2026. The buyer bears the risk, so the SPA should oblige the seller to supply accurate details and cooperate on the filing.
Right to erasure: when must you delete former members, customers and employees?
The right to erasure under GDPR Art. 17 must be honoured when the data is no longer needed, when consent is withdrawn or when an objection under Art. 21 succeeds. A business may keep what the Norwegian Bookkeeping Act requires or what is needed for a specific legal claim. The request must be answered within one month, and striking out a name or marking the person as having left is not erasure.
Who can bind the company when a contract is signed?
The board can always bind the company. A person with signing authority or procuration can also contract on its behalf, as can the chief executive in day-to-day matters. Large or unusual contracts fall outside the chief executive's authority. Someone who signs without authority will usually not bind the company and may personally be liable to the counterparty.
AI agent liability: who pays when an AI agent causes harm?
Under Norwegian law, AI agent liability rests primarily with the business that puts the agent to work. An agent is neither a legal person nor an employee, so the harm is treated as the business's own. Towards customers, ordinary contractual liability applies. The vendor is liable only as far as the contract allows, and the new EU Product Liability Directive does not yet apply in Norway.
Anonymisation under the EDPB guidelines: is your data really anonymous?
Anonymisation under the GDPR requires the likelihood of identifying anyone to be insignificant, assessed from the perspective of whoever will use the data. The draft EDPB guidelines 02/2026 build on the SRB judgment and apply three criteria, singling out, linkability and inference. A processor inherits its customer's perspective, and the assessment must be repeated over time.
Checking AI-generated text: what can businesses learn from a ruling set aside?
Checking AI-generated text means checking it against the source, not against how plausible it sounds. In September 2026 a Norwegian court of appeal set aside a ruling that set out nine paragraphs of submissions no party had made, and the court has confirmed AI was used. The same error in contracts, board papers or replies to regulators binds the business or misleads the board.
Duty to cooperate with the Data Protection Authority: what does it require?
The duty to cooperate under GDPR Art. 31 means a business must answer the Norwegian Data Protection Authority within the deadline and produce the documents it asks for, including contracts with a confidentiality clause. The business may disagree and appeal the order. Threats against case officers and repeated stalling are a breach, and cost Lab Pharma AS a NOK 205,000 fine in August 2026.
Location data: when does tracking become high-risk processing under the GDPR?
Location data becomes high-risk processing when a person's position is tracked systematically over time, particularly employees or app users. Datatilsynet will then usually require a DPIA. The business needs a clear purpose and legal basis, must inform plainly and delete early. Apps reading the phone's position normally also need consent under the Electronic Communications Act § 3-15.
Marketing consent for ‘partners’: what does the Canal+ case mean?
Marketing consent given to ‘our partners’ only covers businesses whose identity the data subject knew when consenting. That is the view of the Advocate General in Canal+ (C-317/25). Any other sender must obtain fresh consent before marketing, and an unsubscribe link in the first email does not cure the defect. The judgment is still to come.
Nordlo judgment: why did the customer get only NOK 8,280 after a cyber attack?
In the Nordlo judgment of 30 June 2026, Gulating Court of Appeal held that Btec AS, which lost its production data in a ransomware attack on its IT supplier and claimed over NOK 57 million, was bound by the supplier's unsigned standard terms. The attack was not force majeure, the supplier was not grossly negligent, and a cap of three months' fees gave NOK 8,280.
Norway's AI agreement: what must employers discuss before introducing AI?
Norway's AI agreement of 2 October 2026 is a letter of intent between the government and the social partners. It places no new obligations on individual employers, whose duties come from the Working Environment Act and collective agreements. If AI changes how work is organised, or can be used to monitor staff, it must be discussed with employee representatives before the decision is made.
Personal data in test environments: can we test with real customer data?
Personal data in test environments may only be used where testing is compatible with the purpose for which the data was collected, under GDPR Art. 6(4), and where synthetic or pseudonymised data will not do. Private businesses have no special rule. Copies of production data used for testing need the same security, access control and deletion as production.
AI hallucinations: who is liable when your chatbot promises a customer too much?
A business is liable for AI hallucinations in its own customer service. The chatbot is not a separate legal person, and what it says counts as the business's own statements. Towards consumers, wrong answers can give rise to claims for non-conformity, and misleading answers can breach Norwegian marketing law. A disclaimer in the chat window helps little.
AI literacy is now a requirement: what Article 4 of the AI Act means for your business
AI literacy is a requirement under Article 4 of the AI Act. Businesses that use AI at work must take measures to build literacy among staff and others who use the systems on their behalf. The requirement has applied in the EU since 2 February 2025 and was softened in July 2026. It does not yet apply in Norway, but should be prepared for now.
AI policy for employees: what can an employer require and monitor?
Under Norwegian law, an employer can set an AI policy for employees under its managerial prerogative, including bans on certain tools and requirements to check the output. Monitoring how employees actually use AI is a control measure that requires objective grounds, discussion with employee representatives and prior information. Continuous monitoring of individual use is generally prohibited.
Board responsibility for AI: what should the board ask before its next meeting?
Board responsibility for AI follows from the general rules of the Norwegian Companies Act. The board must ensure the business is properly organised, subject to adequate control and that the chief executive is supervised, and this also covers the use of artificial intelligence. The board does not need technical expertise, but it must know where AI is used, what the risk is and who is responsible.
Choice of law and jurisdiction: which country's law governs your contract?
Choice of law and jurisdiction clauses decide which country's law governs the contract and where a dispute is resolved. As a rule, the parties can agree both. If the contract is silent, Norwegian law applies the law of the country with the closest connection, while jurisdiction follows the Dispute Act and the Lugano Convention. Choose deliberately, especially under US standard terms.
Cloud exit: how do you secure your data when the contract ends?
A cloud exit must be secured in the contract before it is signed. The contract should give a right to all data in a machine-readable format, assistance from the provider, a transition period and documented deletion. In the EU the Data Act requires at most two months' notice, a 30-day transition and at least 30 days' access to the data. In Norway the regulation does not yet apply.
Cookies and newsletters: when do you need consent in Norway?
Cookies and consent go hand in hand under the Norwegian Electronic Communications Act § 3-15. From 1 January 2025 cookie consent must meet the GDPR requirements, and browser settings are no longer enough. Only strictly necessary cookies are exempt. Email newsletters to private individuals require consent under the Marketing Control Act § 15, with a narrow exception for existing customers.
Copyright and AI: who owns the text, code and images that AI creates?
Content that AI creates entirely on its own probably has no copyright under Norwegian law, because the Copyright Act requires original and individual creative effort by a human. If a human reworks the output creatively, the human contribution may be protected. A vendor's promise that you own the output gives no more protection than the law itself provides.
Transferring personal data to the US: how safe is the Data Privacy Framework?
The Data Privacy Framework makes it lawful to transfer personal data to US companies certified under it. The adequacy decision applies in Norway and was upheld by the EU General Court in 2025, but the case has been appealed and US oversight bodies have been weakened. Businesses should use the framework, but keep standard contractual clauses and an exit plan in reserve.
DPIA for AI tools: when is it required, and what must it contain?
A DPIA for AI tools is required when their use is likely to result in a high risk to data subjects, under GDPR Art. 35. AI tools with access to email, documents, customer data or employee data often meet the threshold. If two or more of the nine criteria in the Article 29 Working Party guidelines are met, you should assume that a DPIA is required.
When can an employer access an employee's email in Norway?
Under Norwegian law, employers may only access an employee's email when access is necessary for day-to-day operations or other legitimate interests, or where there is a well-founded suspicion of serious misconduct. As a rule the employee must be notified in advance and be able to attend. Automatic forwarding counts as unlawful monitoring and has led to administrative fines.
NDA: what should it contain, and what does it not protect?
A non-disclosure agreement (NDA) is a contract under which confidential information may only be used for a specific purpose and must not be passed on. It should define what is confidential, set out exceptions, duration and remedies, and regulate the use of AI tools. It binds only the parties, and it cannot prevent whistleblowing or protect information that is already known.
Personal data breach: what must you do within 72 hours?
A personal data breach must be notified to the Norwegian Data Protection Authority without undue delay and, where feasible, within 72 hours of the business becoming aware of it, unless the breach is unlikely to result in a risk. Where the risk is high, the affected individuals must also be informed. All breaches must be documented, including those that are not notified.
SaaS data processing agreement: what must it contain, and what should you require?
When a SaaS supplier processes personal data on your behalf, GDPR Art. 28 requires a written SaaS data processing agreement. It must cover instructions, confidentiality, security, sub-processors, assistance, deletion and audits, among others. The supplier's standard terms often meet the minimum, but rarely the customer's needs on breach notification, insight, transfers outside the EEA and exit.
SaaS limitation of liability: what holds up under Norwegian law?
A SaaS limitation of liability is, as a rule, valid between businesses under Norwegian law. A liability cap and an exclusion of indirect loss normally hold, but as a starting point they do not protect the supplier against wilful misconduct or gross negligence. Unusual and onerous terms may also fall away as not accepted, be read restrictively or be adjusted under the Contracts Act § 36.
SaaS price increase from your provider: what can you do?
A SaaS price increase requires a basis in the contract. Without a change clause, the agreed price is binding for the contract term. Where the provider has reserved the right to change prices, the clause is generally valid between businesses, but it may be read narrowly or adjusted under section 36 of the Norwegian Contracts Act. The customer's key tools are a right to terminate and an agreed cap.
Subject access requests from staff and customers: deadlines, exemptions and disputes
A subject access request under GDPR Art. 15 must be answered without undue delay and within one month at the latest. The deadline can be extended by two months for complex requests. The requester need not give reasons, and the request cannot be refused because it is used in an employment dispute or litigation. Only exceptionally can a request be refused as manifestly unfounded or excessive.
Your secrets in ChatGPT: can you lose protection for trade secrets?
Trade secrets are only protected if the business has taken reasonable steps to keep them secret. One employee pasting a confidential document into ChatGPT does not normally remove that protection. But if the business lets employees use AI tools freely, without rules and without an enterprise agreement, it becomes hard to show reasonable steps when the secret later has to be enforced.
Vibe lawyering: what is the risk when management drafts contracts with AI?
Vibe lawyering means managers and specialists producing contracts with AI without legal review. The contract binds the company in full, even when it rests on foreign concepts, hallucinated references or liability rules that do not work under Norwegian law. AI can be used for simple agreements, but not without review when a lot is at stake.