legal247

A free service paid for with personal data: can it be advertised as free?

In brief

On 19 November 2026 Advocate General Medina proposed in Case C-643/25 that a digital service is not a free service where consumers must provide personal data for commercial use. If the Court agrees, such marketing falls under point 20 of the Norwegian blacklist of unfair commercial practices, with no need to show that consumers were actually misled.

On 19 November 2026 Advocate General Laila Medina delivered her Opinion in Case C-643/25 Verbraucherzentrale Bundesverband before the Court of Justice of the European Union (press release No 169/26). The question is whether a digital service may be advertised as free when consumers must hand over personal data that the provider uses commercially. The case concerns the Facebook registration page, which in February 2015 displayed the statement ‘Facebook is and remains free’. The Opinion matters directly to Norwegian businesses offering advertising-funded apps and online services to consumers, because the Norwegian prohibition rests on the same directive. This article sets out what the Advocate General proposes, how the proposal applies under Norwegian law, and what businesses should do before judgment is given.

What does the Advocate General propose on a free service and personal data?

The Advocate General proposes that the disclosure of personal data and consent to their commercial use constitute a form of payment under the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive 2005/29/EC. A service therefore cannot be described as free where consumers are required to provide such data. The exception covers data processed exclusively to provide the service or to comply with legal obligations. The German courts had dismissed the consumer association’s action on the basis that the prohibition applies only where consumers bear financial costs, and the Bundesgerichtshof then referred the matter to the Court of Justice.

The reasoning has five elements. In the Advocate General’s view the wording of the directive does not necessarily limit payment to money, and the Court has already accepted that payment may take other forms where the consideration has economic value and a definite link to the commercial practice. Personal data and the consent to their exploitation have economic value for the operator of a social network, because they generate advertising revenue and finance the service. The fact that users retain their data does not prevent the commercial use from being payment. The Advocate General further points out that Directive (EU) 2019/770 on digital services and the Consumer Rights Directive 2011/83/EU recognise business models in which consumers pay with personal data. In her view it would be inconsistent to treat such arrangements as involving consideration under those rules while allowing the same services to be presented as free. Finally, limiting payment to money would undermine consumer protection in the digital economy, where users may be unaware of the economic value of their data or the extent of their exploitation for advertising.

The Advocate General also rejects Meta’s objections. The list of prohibited practices is exhaustive, but that does not mean the terms in the list must be read narrowly. The GDPR governs whether processing is lawful and transparent, whereas the directive governs whether commercial representations are accurate, and the two apply cumulatively. Nor does the proposed interpretation prevent businesses from offering services in exchange for personal data, provided that the services are not called free.

Businesses remain free to offer services in exchange for personal data, but cannot describe them as ‘free’ where such consideration is required.

The Opinion does not bind the Court of Justice, and judgment will follow later. In our assessment the Opinion is well grounded in the systematic link with Directive 2019/770, and businesses should therefore adapt to it now.

How does the Opinion apply under Norwegian law?

The Norwegian prohibition is found in § 1 point 20 of the Regulation on unfair commercial practices, adopted under § 6(5) of the Marketing Control Act. The provision prohibits describing a product as ‘gratis’, ‘vederlagsfri’, ‘uten betaling’ or similar where the consumer must pay anything other than the unavoidable cost of responding to the commercial practice and of collecting or paying for delivery. The Norwegian wording, like the German, uses the verb to pay. That is precisely the term the Advocate General considers not to be limited to money. Since the blacklist is based on Annex I to the directive, the Court’s interpretation will in our assessment also govern the reading of point 20.

Under § 6(5) of the Marketing Control Act the blacklist applies ‘under any circumstances’. The Consumer Authority therefore need not show that the marketing was likely to materially distort consumers’ economic behaviour, as the general rule in § 6(2) requires. The Advocate General makes the same point for the directive. In the event of an infringement the Consumer Authority and the Market Council may impose prohibitions or orders, coercive fines and infringement fines under § 39 of the Act.

Norwegian law has already taken a position on the question in a neighbouring field. § 1(4) of the Digital Content and Services Act (digitalytelsesloven) treats the provision of personal data by the consumer as consideration, unless the supplier processes the data exclusively in order to supply the digital service or to comply with legal obligations. That is the same exception as the one the Advocate General sets out. A business supplying a service for consideration under the Digital Content and Services Act will therefore find it difficult to defend advertising the same service as free. The Act also provides that the Personal Data Act prevails in the event of conflict.

Which services are affected?

The Opinion affects services in which personal data are used for purposes other than providing the service. The typical example is an app or online service funded by targeted advertising, one that sells or shares usage data with advertising partners, or one that uses the data to market other products. In our assessment the same applies to a free trial where the registration data are also used to market products other than the service being trialled.

Services that process data only to provide the service fall outside the scope. A login solution that stores an email address and password to give access is not payment. The line is less clear for analytics and product improvement. The exception applies to data processed ‘exclusively’ for supply, which suggests that use for developing new products or for advertising turns the data into consideration. The question is unresolved, and the position must be reassessed once judgment is given.

The blacklist applies only to dealings with consumers. Marketing a free service to business customers is assessed under the general rules of the Marketing Control Act. SaaS providers selling to both businesses and individuals must assess their consumer-facing marketing separately.

What should businesses do now?

Businesses should review the marketing of their consumer services now, rather than wait for judgment. The word ‘free’ often appears in app store listings, on landing pages and in the registration flow, and the Facebook case concerns precisely such a statement on the registration page. The measures tie in with what the business must document in any event under the GDPR, and with the consent requirements discussed in the article on app tracking and on the data protection topic page.

  1. Map which personal data the service collects, and whether any of them are used for advertising, sharing with third parties or purposes other than providing the service. The record of processing activities and the inventory of SDKs in the app are useful starting points.
  2. Remove the words ‘free’, ‘free of charge’ and ‘no payment’ from the marketing of services where the data are used commercially, and describe instead what the consumer pays in money and what the data are used for.
  3. Check that the description in the marketing matches the privacy notice and the consent solution, so that what the advertising says does not conflict with what actually happens to the data.
  4. Assume that the service is supplied for consideration under the Digital Content and Services Act when the data are used commercially, and align the contract terms with the consumer’s rights under that Act.
  5. Agree with providers of advertising and analytics tools what they may use the data for, because their use may turn an otherwise free service into a service supplied for payment.

Questions and answers

Does the ban on calling a service free also apply to business customers?

No. The blacklist in the Norwegian Regulation on unfair commercial practices is based on § 6 of the Marketing Control Act, which governs commercial practices towards consumers. Marketing a free service to businesses is assessed under the general rules of the Act, not under the blacklist.

Is it sufficient that the privacy notice explains the advertising use?

No, on the Advocate General's approach. The blacklisted practice requires no assessment of whether the consumer was actually misled, and the GDPR and the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive apply cumulatively. Accurate information in the privacy notice therefore does not make the word 'free' in the marketing lawful.

What if the service uses the personal data only to provide the service?

The data are then not payment. The Advocate General excepts data processed exclusively to provide the service or to comply with legal obligations, and § 1(4) of the Norwegian Digital Content and Services Act contains the same exception in its definition of consideration.

Next legal review: 15 December 2026