legal247

Overtime exemption in Norwegian tech: when is a position particularly independent?

In brief

The overtime exemption for a particularly independent position under Working Environment Act § 10-12(2) requires that the employee genuinely decides the volume and timing of the work. Flexible hours are not sufficient, and client deadlines count. Developers, consultants and project managers governed by sprints, deliveries and on-call rotas will therefore rarely be exempt.

On 14 October 2026 the Supreme Court of Norway delivered a unanimous judgment in HR-2026-2227-A on the meaning of the expression «particularly independent position» (særlig uavhengig stilling) in Working Environment Act § 10-12(2). The case concerned a project manager in a construction company who had agreed that normal overtime was included in his salary. After the company went bankrupt, he claimed damages for unpaid overtime personally from the company’s chair, chief executive and principal shareholder under Companies Act § 17-1. Although the judgment concerned the construction sector, the criteria laid down by the Supreme Court have direct implications for technology companies, where the exemption frequently appears in the employment contracts of developers, consultants, product owners and project managers. This article examines what the Supreme Court held, how in our assessment the criteria apply to typical positions in IT, SaaS and consultancy companies, and what financial and personal exposure an incorrect classification entails.

What is a particularly independent position under the Working Environment Act?

An employee in a particularly independent position is exempt from the working time rules in Chapter 10 of the Working Environment Act (arbeidsmiljøloven), with the exception of the basic requirements for proper working hours in Working Environment Act § 10-2(1), (2) and (4). The exemption means, among other things, that the limits on overtime and the requirement of an overtime supplement of at least 40 per cent under Working Environment Act § 10-6(11) do not apply. Because under Working Environment Act § 1-9 the Act cannot be departed from to the detriment of the employee without specific statutory authority, an agreement that overtime is included in the salary is valid only if the position actually falls within an exemption. The Supreme Court did not decide whether such contractual clauses are valid where the exemption does not apply, and that question therefore remains open after the judgment.

Which criteria did the Supreme Court lay down in HR-2026-2227-A?

The Supreme Court held that the provision is a narrow exception (paragraph 27). It is not sufficient that the position offers flexible working hours, since the position must involve a clear and evident independence. Central to the assessment is whether the employee has broad freedom to decide the volume of the work and when it is performed, and the assessment must be specific and take account of all the conditions framing the work (paragraph 39). The preparatory works, which the Supreme Court cited, describe employees who themselves decide what is to be done, what is to be delegated, when the work is to be done and how it is to be carried out.

The employer had argued that only internal conditions, meaning the constraints set by the employer itself, were relevant. The Supreme Court rejected this argument and held that external conditions such as deadlines and requirements imposed by clients or public authorities must also be taken into account (paragraphs 29–31). The reasoning was that the core of the assessment is the individual employee’s control over his or her own working time.

A position which, by reason of external conditions, is not independent cannot become independent under the Act merely because the employer sets no limits on working time. (HR-2026-2227-A paragraph 30, unofficial translation from Nynorsk)

The provision must be interpreted in the light of Article 17(1) of the Working Time Directive 2003/88/EC, and Norwegian law cannot permit exemptions that go further than the Directive (paragraph 33). Under the Directive the employee must be able to determine the duration of the working time, meaning the periods during which the employee is at the employer’s disposal, see Article 2(1) (paragraph 36). The Supreme Court referred to the judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union in Case C-175/16 Hälvä and held that it is not sufficient for the employee to decide at what time of day the work is performed (paragraph 37).

Why was the project manager not exempt?

The project manager led turnkey contracts with project values of up to approximately NOK 100 million and managed as many as five projects at the same time. The chief executive had testified that he never interfered with when the project manager arrived at work. The Supreme Court nevertheless held that the project manager had limited control over his own workload, that he did not freely decide when the work was to be done, and that in reality he could not refuse the tasks assigned to him (paragraphs 44–46). Weight was also given to the fact that he had on several occasions asked for time off in lieu, which indicated that he did not control his own working time (paragraph 45). The judgment of the Court of Appeal was set aside because it had focused too heavily on the work tasks and too little on who decided the working time.

What does the judgment mean for the overtime exemption in IT and SaaS companies?

The judgment says nothing specific about the technology sector, and according to the Supreme Court the assessment is always a specific one. The criteria are nevertheless general, and in our assessment they fit poorly with the way many positions in technology companies are organised. The decisive factor is not how independently the employee carries out the tasks, but who in practice decides how much is to be delivered and when. Employment contracts and other agreements in technology companies are discussed further on the topic page on contracts.

Position Typical framing conditions Assessment under the criteria in the judgment
Developer in an agile team Sprint commitments, prioritised backlog, fixed ceremonies Volume and timing are governed by the team plan and the product delivery
Consultant placed with a client Client deadlines, hourly billing, assignment description External conditions set by the client count, and the hours are already measured
Project manager for client deliveries Milestones, acceptance tests, contractual dates Closest to the facts of HR-2026-2227-A
Product owner Launch dates and priorities set by management May prioritise content, but can rarely control the volume of own working time
Employee on an on-call rota Response times under a service level agreement The employer decides when the employee is to be at its disposal

Developers in agile teams normally work within sprints, with a commitment the team has undertaken and a backlog prioritised by others. Even where the developer freely chooses the place of work and the time of day at which the work is done, this is precisely the kind of flexibility the Supreme Court expressly held to be insufficient. When the sprint goal has not been reached and the delivery to the client is fixed, it is the delivery and not the employee that determines the workload.

Consultants whose hours are sold to clients are in a particularly exposed position. Client deadlines and requirements are exactly the external conditions that the Supreme Court held must be taken into account. In addition, the hours are often recorded for billing purposes. In our assessment this is difficult to reconcile with the premise of the Directive that the duration of working time is not measured or predetermined, or that it can be determined by the employee.

Project managers who run client deliveries against contractual milestones are close to the facts of the judgment. The project manager in that case had considerable professional freedom and significant responsibility, and that was still not sufficient. On-call arrangements requiring the employee to be available within the response times of a service level agreement point in the same direction, because it is the employer and the client contract that decide when the employee is at the employer’s disposal.

Positions that may satisfy the conditions do exist in technology companies as well. In our assessment this applies primarily to persons with independent responsibility for their own field, without delivery obligations controlled by others and with a genuine ability to decline or postpone tasks. Many of them may also hold a managerial position under Working Environment Act § 10-12(1), although the Supreme Court did not address that provision.

What financial exposure does an incorrect classification create?

Where a position has wrongly been treated as particularly independent, the employee is entitled to overtime pay with the supplement under Working Environment Act § 10-6(11) for work beyond the statutory limit for normal working hours. The claim for pay becomes time-barred under the general three-year limitation period in the Limitation Act (foreldelsesloven) § 2, and the period runs from the date on which each salary payment fell due, see Limitation Act § 3(1). A company with many employees in the same type of position may therefore face back-pay claims going up to three years back for each of them.

The evidential risk lies largely with the employer. Under Working Environment Act § 10-7 there must be a record of how much each employee has worked. The duty does not apply to employees who are in fact exempt, but it does apply to everyone who has wrongly been treated as exempt. In the case before the Supreme Court the claim was based on a diary the employee had kept himself, recording the number of hours worked each day. Where the company has no records of its own, the employee’s notes, system logs, time entries for client billing and case management tools may become the best evidence of the extent of the overtime.

When can the board, chief executive or shareholder become personally liable?

Under Companies Act § 17-1 the company, shareholders and others, including an employee, may claim compensation from the chief executive, a board member or a shareholder for loss which that person, acting in that capacity, has caused intentionally or negligently. The project manager in HR-2026-2227-A directed the claim against the chair, who was also chief executive and principal shareholder, because the company was bankrupt and the NAV Wage Guarantee Scheme (Nav Lønnsgaranti) had rejected the claim. The District Court found that the project manager had suffered no loss, and the Court of Appeal found that the chair had not been negligent. Both assessments were based on the premise that the position was particularly independent.

The Supreme Court did not decide whether the chair had been negligent or whether the conditions for personal liability were met. The judgment determined only the interpretation of Working Environment Act § 10-12(2), and the case has been remitted to the Court of Appeal. The judgment therefore provides no clarification of when management is personally liable for unpaid overtime. It does, however, provide a clearer legal starting point for a later assessment of negligence, because the threshold for the exemption has now been settled by the Supreme Court. In our assessment it will be more difficult for the board and the chief executive to rely on an unclear legal position if the company continues a practice that is not consistent with the judgment. Liability may be reduced under Companies Act § 17-2, and a damages claim becomes time-barred under Limitation Act § 9, as a rule three years after the injured party obtained or ought to have obtained knowledge of the loss and of the person responsible. The board’s duties in supervising day-to-day management are discussed further in the article on board responsibility for AI, and the question of who represents the company externally in the article on who can bind the company.

What should technology companies do now?

The judgment gives reason to review every position in which the employment contract or the staff handbook exempts the employee from the working time rules. The review should be carried out position by position and be based on how the work is actually organised, not on title or contractual wording. In our assessment the following measures are the most important.

  1. Identify which employees are described in their contracts as holding a managerial or particularly independent position, or who have agreed that overtime is included in their salary.
  2. Assess for each position who in practice decides the workload and the timing of the work, with emphasis on sprints, client deadlines, milestones and on-call arrangements.
  3. Distinguish between a managerial position under Working Environment Act § 10-12(1) and a particularly independent position under the second paragraph, and give written reasons for which exemption is applied.
  4. Introduce working time recording under Working Environment Act § 10-7 for all positions that do not clearly satisfy the conditions for an exemption.
  5. Consider whether the pay level in positions removed from the exemption should be adjusted, since a high salary alone does not give an exemption and overtime must otherwise be paid in addition.
  6. Discuss changed working time arrangements with the employee representatives where the company has them, in the same way as with other changes to working conditions (see the article on the Norwegian AI agreement for employers).
  7. Calculate the potential back-pay liability for the last three years and present it to the board, so that the board can decide on back payment before claims are brought.

Questions and answers

Is it sufficient that the employment contract describes the position as particularly independent?

No. Under Working Environment Act § 1-9 the Act cannot be departed from to the detriment of the employee, and the assessment under § 10-12(2) concerns the actual content of the position. In HR-2026-2227-A the Supreme Court assessed how the work was in fact organised, and a contractual clause cannot make a position independent when the employee does not in practice control the volume and timing of the work.

Does a high salary make a position particularly independent?

The Supreme Court did not treat the level of pay as a criterion for a particularly independent position. The judgment mentions that pay and title may be relevant to whether a position is managerial under § 10-12(1), but that they are not decisive. A high salary therefore cannot replace genuine control over the employee's own working time.

How far back can an employee claim overtime pay?

Claims for pay become time-barred under the general three-year limitation period in Limitation Act § 2, calculated from the date on which each salary payment fell due, see § 3. A damages claim against board members or the chief executive under Companies Act § 17-1 becomes time-barred under Limitation Act § 9, as a rule three years after the injured party obtained or ought to have obtained knowledge of the loss and of the person responsible.

Next legal review: 15 November 2026