legal247

Holiday pay and multiple contracts with one employer: what does C-706/23 mean in Norway?

In brief

In C-706/23 of 8 October 2026 the Court of Justice held that holiday pay and meal allowances for an employee with multiple contracts with the same employer cannot be based on the full-time contract alone. Norwegian holiday pay is already calculated on all remuneration paid under Holiday Act § 10, so the ruling matters mainly for contractual benefits tied only to the main position.

On 8 October 2026 the Court of Justice of the European Union delivered its judgment in Case C-706/23 (Şcoala gimnazială «Mihai Eminescu») on how holiday pay and meal allowances are to be calculated when an employee holds two contracts of employment with the same employer. The case was a reference for a preliminary ruling from the Court of Appeal of Iași in Romania. The judgment is summarised in the Court’s Press Release No 142/26, on which the account below is based.

What was the case on holiday pay and multiple contracts about?

The case concerned fourteen teachers who, between 2019 and 2022, held permanent full-time positions in Romanian schools. At the same schools they also worked under fixed-term, part-time arrangements paid by the hour from September to June of each school year. As Romanian legislation required, the employer calculated holiday pay and meal allowances on the basis of the full-time contract alone. Through their trade union, the teachers claimed that the hours worked under the part-time arrangement should also count pro rata. The Regional Court of Vaslui upheld their claim in 2023, and the Court of Appeal of Iași asked the Court of Justice whether EU law precludes a national rule under which such entitlements are calculated solely by reference to the permanent full-time contract.

What did the Court of Justice decide?

The Court took as its starting point the right to at least four weeks of paid annual leave under Article 7(1) of the Working Time Directive 2003/88/EC. During annual leave the worker must receive remuneration that places him or her in a position comparable to periods of work. Because the part-time hours had been excluded, the Court also examined the framework agreements annexed to Directives 97/81/EC and 1999/70/EC. It held that the same employee was both a fixed-term worker and a part-time worker within the meaning of those agreements, and that the meal allowance was an employment condition. The prohibition of less favourable treatment in clause 4 of both framework agreements must not be interpreted restrictively and applies even where one employee holds two contracts. The difference in treatment was not objectively justified, and the pro rata temporis principle had not been applied correctly. EU law therefore precludes legislation such as the Romanian rule.

How is holiday pay calculated in Norway for employees with several contracts?

The Norwegian Holiday Act takes a different approach from the Romanian legislation. Under Holiday Act § 10(1), holiday pay is calculated on all remuneration for work paid by the employer during the accrual year, without distinguishing between positions or contracts. Hourly pay from an additional assignment therefore forms part of the holiday pay basis in the same way as fixed salary, and the statutory rate is at least 10.2 per cent under Holiday Act § 10(2). An employer in Norway that complies with the Act will not find itself in the situation the Court of Justice addressed, and on this point the ruling has limited direct relevance. In our assessment the risk lies in payroll arrangements where additional assignments are paid through a separate scheme, for example as fees, and the payments are wrongly left out of the basis.

Where may the ruling matter for employers in Norway?

The ruling is most relevant in Norway for contractual benefits that go beyond the Holiday Act. Under Working Environment Act § 13-1(3), the anti-discrimination rules in Chapter 13 of the Working Environment Act apply correspondingly to employees who work part-time or are employed on a fixed-term basis, and under Working Environment Act § 13-2(1)(c) the prohibition covers pay and working conditions. Those rules must be read in the light of the two framework agreements, which were incorporated into the EEA Agreement by EEA Joint Committee Decisions No 104/1998 and No 43/2000. The Court of Justice’s interpretation will therefore ordinarily carry considerable weight in Norway. Benefits tied only to the main position, such as meal allowances, bonuses, supplements or certain staff benefits, should after the ruling also be granted pro rata for work performed under a fixed-term additional contract with the same employer.

Under Working Environment Act § 13-3(2), different treatment is lawful only where it is necessary to achieve a legitimate aim and is not disproportionate. In the event of a breach, the employee may claim compensation for financial loss and non-pecuniary damage without proof of fault under Working Environment Act § 13-9(1), and contractual terms contrary to the chapter are void under § 13-9(2).

The ruling nonetheless has limited transferability in several respects. It concerned a statutory rule in the Romanian public sector. Nor is it certain that Norwegian law would treat an additional contract with the same employer as a separate employment relationship. Work beyond normal working hours for the same employer may constitute overtime under Norwegian law, in which case the overtime rules in Working Environment Act § 10-6, rather than the prohibition of less favourable treatment of part-time workers, become the practical issue. Exemptions from the overtime rules are discussed in the article on the overtime exemption for particularly independent positions. The Court also relied on the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights, which is not part of the EEA Agreement, although its conclusion rests primarily on the directives.

What should employers with several contracts per employee do?

Employers that enter into additional contracts with their own staff should review how those contracts are handled in payroll and HR systems. Employment and other commercial contracts are discussed further on the contracts topic page.

  1. Verify that all remuneration paid under additional contracts is included in the holiday pay basis under Holiday Act § 10(1).
  2. Review staff handbooks and collective agreements for benefits calculated solely by reference to the main position.
  3. Assess whether any difference in treatment pursues a legitimate aim and is proportionate under Working Environment Act § 13-3(2), and record the assessment.
  4. Consider whether the additional work is in reality overtime that must be paid with a supplement under Working Environment Act § 10-6.
  5. Estimate the potential back-pay liability within the general limitation period for pay claims and present it to management.

Questions and answers

Does the judgment in C-706/23 apply directly to employers in Norway?

The judgment concerns Romanian legislation and does not bind Norwegian courts directly. The Part-Time Work Directive, the Fixed-Term Work Directive and the Working Time Directive have all been incorporated into the EEA Agreement, and the Court of Justice's interpretation of them will therefore ordinarily carry considerable weight when the Norwegian rules implementing them are construed.

Should a meal allowance be included in the basis for holiday pay?

Under Holiday Act § 10(1), payments covering the cost of meals are not remuneration for work and are therefore excluded from the holiday pay basis. The Court of Justice treated the meal allowance as an employment condition under the prohibition of less favourable treatment, not as holiday pay. In Norwegian law the question is therefore whether the allowance is granted pro rata for all working time under Working Environment Act § 13-1(3).

May an employer justify treating an additional contract less favourably?

Under Working Environment Act § 13-3(2), different treatment of part-time and fixed-term employees is lawful only where it is necessary to achieve a legitimate aim and is not disproportionate. In our assessment, administrative convenience or the fact that the work is paid by the hour will rarely suffice, and the Court of Justice found no objective justification in the Romanian case.

Next legal review: 15 November 2026